Gender Pay Gaps in the Western World

There are substantial differences in the size of gender gap pays around the world. The analysis of Olivetti and Petrongolo gives an interesting perspective on this, cross-referencing data from the United States, the United Kingdom, and the EU countries. There evidence points toward three main groups within these countries: the United States and the United Kingdom being the most unequal, then central and northern Europe, and then the central and southern European states making up the last and most equal group. There is also a striking variation in employment gaps internationally, which are parallel to the gender gap pay differences.

So why is this? Petrongolo and Olivetti argue that it might stem from the differences in labor supply behavior and the role of household composition and social norms. Also, differences in social attitudes toward female employment may play a big role. Unionization of labor markets and minimum wage levels could also play a role. The countries where men typically provide for the household and women stay at home with the children, i.e. southern and central Europe, usually feature smaller gender gap pays. Countries such as the US and Canada, where it is typical for both parents to work, are usually more unequal in payment. The reason for this is probably the different process of selection into employment rather than more equal pay. As female participation rates in Catholic countries and Greece (southern Europe) are typically low and only concentrated on the high-end spectrum, it therefore makes sense that statistically there are less wage gaps for these high-wage jobs. If corrected for lower participation rates, the wage gap itself becomes akin to that of the Anglo-Saxon countries (i.e. Northern and central Europe, Canada and the USA). The Anglo-Saxon countries have corrected this gender participation gap problem, yet the wage gap either remains the same or grows.

Olivetti and Petrongolo come to the conclusion that disentangling supply and demand factors for female employment if the next step for understanding existing variation in gender pay gaps. They mention the work of Fernandez and Fogli, and Fortin, which emphasize the role of “soft variables” such as the cultural beliefs about gender roles and family values, as well as the individual attitudes towards greed, ambition, and altruism. These might just be the most defining factors in the gender wage gap.

Even in our modern world, we find high gender wage gaps in those countries we typically consider the most developed. Although there has been some progress from the 1930s to the 1980s, the gender wage gap shrink stalled out over the last twenty years. To continue work to resolve this problem, we must find the reason for it existing in the first place.

From:
Unequal Pay or Unequal Employment? A Cross‐Country Analysis of Gender Gaps
By Claudia Olivetti and Barbara Petrongolo
Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. 26, No 4 (October 2008) pp. 621-654

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Gender Pay Gaps in the Western World

  1. I agree, it is of course a weird and unreal situation that different genders get paid different for the same job or situation. In general it would be better for both genders to get paid by how much value they add with their job. This might be difficult in certain jobs, but it might resolve problems in other sectors. This way people don’t get paid for the sort of job but how good they are at it, no matter what gender and other factors.

    Reply
  2. In the UK, equal pay acts were introduced between men and women in 1888 and great strides have been made for women both in the labour market and in society. However, the persistence of a significant gender pay gap points not only to women’s continuing experience of discrimination within the workplace, but to other trends that have a serious impact on women’s lives, such as occupational segregation, a disproportionate
    share of caring responsibilities, lack of well-paid, high quality part time work and the undervaluation of work done by women.

    Reply
  3. No matter how developed and progressive countries are it is no secret that differences between men and women wages still exist. Often when choosing an employee, this choice is made not based on skills and education but on gender. But it is important to remember that in this case both- men and women- can become a victims of discrimination.

    Reply
  4. The issue of lower payments for women in the developed countries is upsetting, and in my point of view is way behind the state of development in the Western Europe. How can this happen in a society where educational systems are equally accessible for men and women and it is proven to be as justifiable, no matter if its male or female? The social shift from a women being only assigned to raise children is long in the past and it is amazing how women manage studying nowadays, working and caring about the family, everything in the same time. This qualified woman, doing the same job as a man, and who is getting paid less, is a sign of the weakness from the male to fully acknowledge the woman’s intelligence and potential.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s